Records requests & recoupment
Medical records requests from payer vendors: can you fight the audit and the takeback?
The letter comes from a company like Datavant or Cotiviti, gives you days to comply, and warns of a takeback if you’re late. Providers ask us the same four questions: who is this, can I refuse, is that deadline even legal, and what happens if I miss it. Here are the answers.
The records demand
What actually happens when the letter arrives.
This guide concerns commercial health plans’ bulk, retrospective audits of claims you were already paid on, for care you already delivered. A plan (or a vendor working for it) asks for a bulk pull of chart notes across many patients, a reviewer second-guesses the documentation months later, and if the notes don’t satisfy the plan’s medical-necessity policy, the money is taken back by offsetting your future checks. It is a defined, repeatable process, which means there are defined places to push back. Here is the path, start to finish.
The demand
A retrieval vendor (Datavant, MRO, Verisma) requests a year of notes across dozens of patients on a short deadline.
You produce charts
Your team pulls and sends the notes: complete, legible, and on time, or the claim fails by default.
The review
A payment-integrity reviewer (Cotiviti, Optum) judges the notes against the plan’s medical-necessity policy.
Overpayment
Visits the notes don’t support are tallied into an overpayment demand you’re asked to repay.
Recoupment
If it isn’t repaid, the plan takes it out of your next checks, across other patients, under your TIN.
Who is asking
Who is actually asking, and by what authority.
The letterhead is usually a company you’ve never contracted with, and that unnerves providers. Here is the key fact: none of these vendors act on their own authority. Each is the health plan’s HIPAA business associate, working under the plan’s permission to review already-paid claims for “payment” and “health care operations” (45 CFR 164.506, 164.502(e)). They come in two types.
They pull the charts
Release-of-information / retrieval vendors that physically request and collect your records:
Datavant (which absorbed Ciox Health and ChartSwap), MRO, Sharecare Health Data Services, Verisma (which absorbed ScanSTAT), Ontellus, Inovalon, Episource, Reveleer.
They run the review
Payment-integrity vendors that judge the notes and drive the takeback:
Cotiviti, Optum / Optum Insight (which owns Change Healthcare and Episource), EXL, Machinify (which absorbed Performant), Lyric (formerly ClaimsXten), Zelis.
It’s often the same company under a new name. Ciox and ChartSwap are now Datavant. ScanSTAT is now Verisma. Change Healthcare and Episource are now Optum. Performant is now Machinify. ClaimsXten is now Lyric. A stack of different letterheads can trace back to just a few parents, so identify the plan behind the letter, not just the vendor on it.
Can you refuse?
Can you refuse? Mostly no. But you have real leverage.
The honest answer: if you participate with the plan, your network contract requires you to cooperate with a legitimate payment audit. HIPAA only permits the disclosure; the contract compels it. Aetna’s Medicare Advantage manual section warns that failure to respond may affect future participation, and UnitedHealthcare’s 2026 audit provisions require access to requested records. A flat refusal is a breach that triggers denial or recoupment on its own. So you rarely get to say no. What you can do is narrow it, verify it, and slow it down.
Verify who’s really asking
Confirm the named plan, the vendor’s authority and the purpose of the request (45 CFR 164.514(h)). A letterhead alone does not establish a right to your records. HIPAA payment activities can include health-benefit subrogation; requests outside the permitted purposes need a separate legal basis or patient authorization.
Narrow the request
HIPAA’s minimum-necessary rule (45 CFR 164.514(d)) says a requester “may not request an entire medical record” unless that is specifically justified. An overbroad “send everything” demand can be narrowed to the dates and elements actually at issue. It is a negotiation with a strong basis, not an automatic veto.
Push on the timeline
Ask for an extension in writing. Show the chart volume, propose a delivery date and take the request from the vendor to the plan when needed. Use your contract, the plan’s manual and applicable state law to support the request; keep working to the existing deadline until a change is confirmed.
Out of network? More room
With no participation contract there’s no cooperation clause to breach, so a refusal isn’t a breach. The plan can still deny or recoup the patient’s claim, so the leverage is real but limited.
When a refusal is actually defensible: the requester can’t prove it’s acting for the plan; the request is outside treatment, payment or operations and has no patient authorization; or it reaches specially protected data such as psychotherapy notes (164.508(a)(2)) or substance-use records under 42 CFR Part 2 without the required consent, authorization or another permitted disclosure basis. One thing to avoid: don’t assume you can bill the plan for audit copies. You generally can’t for a plan’s own audit, even though a patient’s right-of-access copy (164.524) and an attorney’s request follow separate fee rules.
The 8-day clock
Eight days for a year of charts? You can push back.
Start with the plan’s own rules. Compare the vendor’s letter with your participation contract, the applicable provider manual and state law, then make a written case for more time. An eight-day deadline is not automatically unlawful, but you can challenge it. Keep the clocks straight: UnitedHealthcare’s 2026 audit section uses the deadline in the intent-to-audit letter; its separate refund and offset periods do not give you 45 days to produce charts.
Records production: a deadline a vendor’s letter may set. Verify the applicable rule and request a written extension before it expires.
UHC audit refund remittance: from receipt of the refund request, unless applicable law requires otherwise. This is a repayment clock.
UHC audit offsets: after the refund request date, with exceptions for repayment, timely written disagreement, or contrary contract or state-law terms.
Request the extension before records are due. Identify the chart volume, explain any access or scope issue and propose a delivery date. If the vendor will not help, escalate to the plan and ask for written confirmation. An extension request alone does not stop the clock. If a refund demand follows, separately log its disagreement deadline and any offset date. For comparison, Original Medicare post-payment ADRs generally allow 45 calendar days for MAC, RAC, SMRC or CERT requests and 30 for UPIC requests; those federal windows do not govern commercial audits.
If you missed it
Missed the deadline and got a takeback? It’s almost never the end.
When late records trigger a takeback, the job changes from preventing a denial to challenging one. Put the charts and refund notice together, identify the deadline for a dispute, and respond with a clear documentation defense. The notice and your contract set the available process. Four places to push back:
Submit the records late
Bring the charts into the dispute. Ask for the late records to be reviewed on their merits, explain the delay and submit them through the plan’s reconsideration or appeal process. Follow the commercial plan’s notice and contract for its filing period. Original Medicare contractors may accept late ADR records for good cause (42 CFR 405.929).
Appeal the recoupment
File the payer’s audit dispute or appeal by the stated deadline, and ask whether a timely dispute pauses offsets. External review is available when the denial and appellant qualify. For an ERISA plan, establish your authority to use its claims appeal. Original Medicare limits recoupment during qualifying redetermination and reconsideration, not every later appeal stage (42 CFR 405.379).
Invoke your state’s cap
If the takeback reaches past your state’s lookback window, or skips a required notice, it may be barred outright (the matrix below). Start with the plan’s funding and applicable state rule. Exceptions differ by state; a fraud allegation alone does not remove every cap.
Make them prove the number
Demand the specific claims and notes at issue and, for an extrapolated bulk demand, the sampling methodology. Send a complete records package with the appeal by certified delivery, and complain to your state insurance regulator for an out-of-window or no-notice offset.
For a self-funded ERISA plan, use the plan’s appeal procedure and review the contract terms behind the offset. If the records do not support the billed care, a deadline argument alone may not resolve the dispute. An attorney can assess remaining contractual or legal options.
Why chiropractic
Why chiropractic draws more of these than almost any specialty.
If you feel singled out, the data explains it. The whole audit turns on one line the record has to draw every visit: active, corrective care that is improving the patient is covered. Maintenance, holding a stable patient steady, is not. Most recoupments come from that line being blurry in the notes.
improper-payment rate of any Medicare Part B service. Chiropractic’s rate rose from about 44% to 54% between 2010 and 2014 (HHS-OIG CERT data).
of paid chiropractic claims OIG reviewed were for maintenance therapy the plan doesn’t cover. The error climbs with the number of visits per patient.
in unallowable chiropractic payments OIG has cited, which is why chiropractic keeps returning to auditors’ work plans, public and commercial alike.
Those figures are Medicare and OIG data, the backdrop for why you’re a target. The standard that decides a commercial takeback is each plan’s own medical-necessity policy, and that is what your notes have to satisfy.
Notes that survive
The same visit, two charts. One holds up, one gets clawed back.
The care can be identical. What decides the audit is whether the note proves it, against the current commercial policies (Cigna CPG 278, UnitedHealthcare 2026T0541X, Aetna CPB 0107). The hard truth: good care with bad notes still loses. This is the checklist to self-audit against.
Survives the review
- An individualized, contemporaneous note, written for this patient, this visit.
- A plan with a set number of visits over a set timeframe, and the outcome you expect.
- Relevant spinal findings and how they explain the patient’s symptoms. For Original Medicare, a physical-exam demonstration of subluxation needs two PART findings, including asymmetry/misalignment or a range-of-motion abnormality.
- Objective outcome measures re-scored at intervals, with measurable improvement between them.
- When the patient plateaus, maintenance called what it is, and handed off with an ABN where required.
Gets recouped
- Cloned or templated notes that read identically visit after visit (Cigna bans this outright).
- “Pain 6/10, feels better,” a subjective score with no objective measure behind it.
- A frequency of care the notes never justify, like three visits a week, indefinitely.
- No re-examination: goals set once and never re-measured.
- A stable patient still billed as active care: maintenance in everything but the label.
Insured or ERISA?
One question decides which protections you have: who bears the risk?
Before citing a deadline or lookback, identify the plan’s funding and whether ERISA governs it. The same national insurance logo can appear on different plan types.
Fully-insured (state law applies)
The carrier bears the risk, so the state regulates it. The lookback caps, the notice-before-offset rules and the external-review rights below are all available to you.
Self-funded employer plan governed by ERISA
The employer bears the risk and the carrier administers the benefits. ERISA generally preempts state insurance recoupment rules for these plans. Check the plan documents, your authority to appeal and the applicable federal procedure. An ASO label alone does not settle ERISA status; governmental and certain church plans have different rules.
How to tell: the member ID card and EOB (“insured by” vs. “administered by,” a third-party administrator), the summary plan description, or simply ask at eligibility. It’s always step one.
Your state’s limit
How far back a fully-insured plan can reach, and whether it can offset before you’re heard.
For state-regulated plans, lookback limits and notice rules can give you grounds to challenge a takeback. Check the applicable statute, its exceptions and the date of payment before conceding a refund. The table summarizes ordinary paid-claim recovery rules; a short records deadline and a refund or offset deadline are different clocks.
These state-law protections depend on the plan and the statute’s scope. Self-funded employer plans governed by ERISA generally fall outside state insurance recoupment limits. Confirm funding and ERISA status before abandoning a deadline or notice objection.
| State | Recoupment lookback (fully-insured) | Can they offset before you’re heard? | Prompt-pay + interest |
|---|---|---|---|
| California | DMHC plans: 365 days from payment | Offset of an uncontested reimbursement notice only if it remains unpaid after 30 working days and the written contract specifically authorizes it; contest in writing with the basis within 30 working days after receipt. | 30 calendar days for complete claims from January 1, 2026; 15%/yr overdue |
| Texas | 180 days from your receipt of payment | Strong; no recovery until your appeal rights are exhausted | 30 days electronic / 45 days paper; tiered late-payment penalties |
| Florida | Chiropractors: 12 months (30 mo general) | No offset without your written agreement or an untimely response; 35 days to contest | Electronic: 20 days to pay/deny/contest, 90 to settle; paper: 40/120 days; 12%/yr overdue |
| Washington | 24 months | Written request; 30 days to contest; a contested refund can’t be offset for 6 months | 95% of clean claims paid within 30 days; 95% of all claims paid/denied within 60; 1%/mo under the late-payment rule |
| Illinois | 12 months | Itemized remittance explanation and appeal instructions; appeal within 60 days after receipt of the remittance advice. | 30 days after due written proof of loss; 9%/yr on overdue benefits |
| Georgia | Notice within 12 months of the last service or discharge date. For claims submitted within 90 days, complete the audit within 18 months of that date; later submissions use the earlier of 18 months after submission or 24 months after service. | Written notice must identify the claim and the specific audit or retroactive-denial reason. | 15 working days electronic / 30 calendar days paper; 12%/yr on overdue benefits |
| Colorado | Contract adjustment period, at most 12 months after the original explanation of benefits; 12 months from that EOB if there is no contract. The separate six-month rule concerns risk-sharing reconciliation. | Written notice with a specific explanation and the dispute process | 30/45 days; 10%/yr (+20% at day 91) |
| Pennsylvania | 24 months | Written statement of the basis; requested records must be provided within 60 days, and the time spent gathering them is added to the 24-month limit. | 45 days; 10%/yr |
| New Jersey | 18 months | Written reimbursement request; no collection on or before day 45 after submission of the request. Dispute and initiate an appeal by day 45 to pause collection until appeal rights are exhausted. | 30/40 days; 12%/yr |
| New York | 24 months (self-funded expressly carved out; a pending bill to cut this to 12 months has not been enacted) | 30 days’ written notice before additional recovery efforts, plus an opportunity to challenge. | 30 days electronic / 45 days paper; greater of 12%/yr or the statutory corporate-tax interest rate |
| North Carolina | 2 years | 30 days’ advance written notice before offset | 30 days; 18%/yr |
| Ohio | 1 year from payment under the rule effective October 7, 2026; recovery must start within that year (fraud exception). Check the applicable version for earlier payments or notices. | Notice with a no-fee appeal; respond or appeal within 60 days after notice is made. Recovery can begin after no timely response or denial of the appeal. | 30/45 days; 18%/yr |
| Arizona | 1-year default from payment or denial; a contract may set a different adjustment period if both parties have the same period. | Adjustment request within the applicable default or equal contractual period; no express pre-offset stay in the cited section. | Clean claim adjudication within 30 days, then approved-claim payment within 30 days after adjudication, unless applicable contractual periods control; late-payment interest at the legal rate. |
Operative sections: CA 28 CCR §1300.71; TX Ins. Code §843.350 / §1301.132; FL §627.6131 & §641.3155 (ch. 460 in the 12-month tier); WA RCW 48.43.600; IL 215 ILCS 5/368d; GA O.C.G.A. §33-20A-62; CO C.R.S. §10-16-704(4.5); PA 40 Pa.C.S. §3803; NJ N.J.A.C. 11:22-1.8; NY Ins. Law §3224-b; NC N.C.G.S. §58-3-225; OH R.C. §3901.388; AZ A.R.S. §20-3102. Confirm the applicable statute, exceptions, contract and date before using a limit. Payment periods concern complete claims; the receipt and documentation triggers matter.
What to do now
The short version, in the order it matters.
Most of these audits are won or lost on procedure, not the merits. Here is the sequence that keeps a records demand from becoming a silent takeback.
This is the day-to-day work ACB does for chiropractic practices: fielding the demand, hitting the clocks, coaching audit-ready documentation, and running the appeal to the finish, inside the EHR you already use. It pairs with our active vs. maintenance and denials guides.
Common questions
Records requests and takebacks, answered.
Datavant is a medical-records retrieval company (it absorbed Ciox Health and ChartSwap) that pulls charts on behalf of health plans. It doesn’t act on its own authority; it’s the plan’s HIPAA business associate, and the plan’s right to review already-paid claims without patient authorization comes from HIPAA’s payment and operations rules (45 CFR 164.506). Others do the same job (MRO, Verisma, Sharecare), and separate firms like Cotiviti and Optum run the review. So yes, a legitimate request tied to a plan you participate with is one you generally have to answer, but you can make them prove who they represent first.
Rarely. If you participate with the plan, your contract requires you to cooperate with a legitimate payment audit, and a flat refusal is a breach that triggers denial or recoupment by itself. HIPAA permits the disclosure; your contract compels it. What you can do is narrow an overbroad request under the minimum-necessary rule (45 CFR 164.514(d)), make the vendor prove it’s the plan’s business associate, and push on the deadline. A true refusal is defensible only in narrow cases, such as a request with no proof of authority, or one reaching psychotherapy notes or Part 2 substance-use records without the required consent, authorization or another permitted disclosure basis.
A short deadline is not automatically unlawful. Check the audit letter against your contract, the applicable manual and state law, then request a written extension with a proposed delivery date. The UHC audit section sets records production by the intent-to-audit letter; its 45-day offset period follows a refund request and is not extra time for charts. Keep meeting the current deadline unless a change is confirmed.
A missed records deadline does not eliminate every way to challenge a takeback. Start with the refund notice: identify the disagreement or appeal deadline, request review of the late records, and ask whether a timely dispute pauses offsets. Keep proof of submission and check any applicable state lookback limit. Original Medicare contractors may accept late ADR records for good cause; a commercial plan uses the process in its notice and contract. The records deadline and the deadline to dispute the refund are separate clocks.
You have a real basis to. HIPAA’s minimum-necessary standard says a requester “may not request an entire medical record” unless that is specifically justified (45 CFR 164.514(d)), so you can ask them to limit the pull to the dates of service and elements actually under review. It’s a negotiation, not an automatic veto, since the rule lets the requester rely on its own judgment of what it needs, but a documented push to narrow the scope is both reasonable and useful if the audit is later appealed.
Official sources
Where these answers come from
Follow the source for the plan, state and date involved in your dispute. The state table summarizes general provisions; statutory exceptions and individual contract terms still matter.
- CMS: Benefit Policy Manual, Chapter 15, chiropractic coverage and examination evidence
- 45 CFR 164.501: payment and operations definitions
- CMS: Financial Management Manual, Chapter 3, limitation on recoupment during appeals
- Ohio: overpayment recovery, effective October 7, 2026
- Arizona: adjustment periods and claim-payment steps
- UnitedHealthcare: 2026 Administrative Guide, audit access, refunds & offsets (pp. 155–157)
- CMS: Program Integrity Manual, Chapter 3, § 3.2.3.2 (ADR time frames)
- 45 CFR § 164.506: HIPAA payment & operations disclosures (the records basis)
- 45 CFR § 164.502(e) & 164.504(e): business-associate relationship (the vendor’s authority)
- 45 CFR § 164.514(d) & (h): minimum necessary & verification of the requester
- HHS OCR: treatment, payment & operations disclosures are permitted, not required
- CMS: post-payment records requests and good-cause late records (42 CFR 405.929)
- 42 CFR § 405.379: Medicare recoupment pauses during a timely appeal
- 29 U.S.C. § 1144: ERISA preemption (self-funded plans)
- 29 CFR § 2560.503-1: ERISA claims & appeals procedure
- HHS-OIG: chiropractic improper-payment findings (maintenance care; $350M+)
- HHS-OIG: 2015 chiropractic report (historical maintenance-care findings)
- California DMHC: 2026 Knox-Keene Act and regulations, payment and recovery rules
- California DMHC: AB 3275, claim reimbursement changes effective January 1, 2026
- Tex. Ins. Code § 843.350: recovery of overpayment (Texas)
- Fla. Stat. § 641.3155: overpayment recovery; ch. 460 in the 12-month tier (Florida)
- RCW 48.43.600: overpayment recovery time limits (Washington)
- N.Y. Ins. Law § 3224-b: overpayment recovery; self-insured carve-out (New York)
- Cigna Coverage Policy CPG 278: Chiropractic Care (eff. 12/15/2025)
- Aetna Clinical Policy Bulletin 0107: Chiropractic Services
- Aetna: Office Manual, Medicare Advantage records requirements
- HHS: Part 2 consent and disclosure framework (2026 compliance date)
- UnitedHealthcare: Manipulative Therapy, Commercial/Exchange (June 1, 2026)
- Texas Department of Insurance: prompt payment and recovery procedures
- Washington WAC 284-170-431: claim-volume payment standards
- New York Insurance Law 3224-a: payment deadlines and interest
- Pennsylvania: Insurance Company Law, section 2166, clean-claim payment and interest
- Illinois: 215 ILCS 5/368a(c), payment after due written proof of loss and interest
- Evernorth: September 2026 Georgia regulatory addendum, statutory audit notice and completion periods
- UnitedHealthcare of Georgia: 2026 commercial policy, page 42, payment deadlines and annual interest
This guide is part of our chiropractic billing guides. For the documentation that keeps these claims audit-proof, see active vs. maintenance care, the Medicare billing rules, and the denials playbook.
This guide is general information for chiropractic and multi-specialty practices, not legal advice. Whether you can push back on a request, and what you can do about a takeback, turns on plan-specific facts: your participation contract, the plan’s funding type, the member’s benefit, and your state’s current statute. Verify the current rule for each situation and consult counsel for a specific dispute above a material dollar amount. American Chiropractic Billing helps clients respond to records audits, meet the deadlines and pursue appeals as part of its billing service; we are a billing company, not a law firm.
Got a records demand or a takeback?
Let us help you.
Book a free 30-minute appointment. We’ll read the demand, check who’s behind it, the plan type and your state’s lookback, and map the response before the offset hits. Chiropractic-first, month-to-month, no contract.
HIPAA-regulated · BAA available · Any-EHR compatible · Serving all 50 states · Since 2020
